Open Letter to the Israeli and U.S. Governments and Others Weaponizing the Issue of Rape
All too often in the fog of war, the brutality of sexual assault and rape is lost in the public eye, and bringing these abuses to light is something for which feminists have fought for decades. Complicating this issue, however, is the fact that accusations of sexual assault have also been wielded as a tool of war – and as an (often lethal) weapon of racism and colonialism.
In its current war against the people of Gaza, the Israeli government has chosen to weaponize the issue of sexual violence for political outcome. The statement below will be delivered to officials of the Israeli government who have mounted a public crusade manipulating this issue to both legitimize – and divert attention from – their campaign of ethnic cleansing, to dehumanize Palestinians, and to vilify those who criticize their actions. It will also be sent to U.S. officials, prominent public figures and others who, with intention or misguidedly, have joined the fray by demonizing a variety of feminist organizations and individuals. In some cases, these attacks have included orchestrated campaigns to withdraw funding for critical work. They have also fueled harassment and doxing of staff or board members that, reprehensibly, has included threats of rape and death.
The statement was initiated by U.S.-based anti-zionist Jewish feminists who believe we have a particular responsibility to speak out in support of Palestinian rights and against the current genocide. It has since garnered support from across the U.S. and throughout the world. Many of the signers have worked on or researched the issue of sexual violence for decades. Many have directly supported survivors and/or are survivors ourselves. Collectively, we are accustomed to holding complicated realities in our minds, which we believe to be a necessary practice in a complex and unjust world.
The signers of this statement stand together both in condemning all instances of war crimes – including sexual violence – and in defending those who are under attack for challenging Israel’s deadly assault on Palestinians.
In the face of these attempts to intimidate or discredit us, we refuse to be silenced.
OPEN LETTER TO THE ISRAELI AND U.S. GOVERNMENTS AND OTHERS WEAPONIZING THE ISSUE OF RAPE
We, the undersigned, are responding to the disgraceful coordinated offensive currently being leveled against feminist, women’s advocacy, Jewish anti-zionist, and other organizations, agencies and individuals, accusing us of “failing to condemn” reported systematic sexual assaults of Israeli women and children in the brutal October 7 attack by Hamas. We repudiate the attempts by the Israeli government, and its apologists, to delegitimize our work, defund social justice and feminist organizations, and undermine our demands that Israel cease its genocidal massacre of Palestinians.
Whether we identify as feminists, as Jews, as anti-zionists, as all of the above, or as allies, and wherever we are based in the world, we proclaim that we can hold many truths simultaneously in our heads and in our hearts; that is what we do every minute of every day. We excoriate rape and all forms of sexual assault against anyone of any gender or age – whether perpetrated by Hamas, the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) or anyone else. We also excoriate carpet bombing of civilians, deadly blockades of food, water and fuel, use of illegal chemical weapons, targeted murders of journalists and aid workers, decimation of homes, hospitals, schools, houses of worship, infrastructure and entire family lines, annihilation of culture, kidnapping and hostage-taking, and all war crimes when committed by any party.
For those of us who are Jewish, we embrace our Jewish identity and its history of facing down injustice and we also condemn the actions of the state created in our name that was birthed in massacre and mass expulsion, that has maintained a stifling, racist and dehumanizing occupation for 75 years, and that is currently conducting mass murder of civilians daily with impunity.
WE CONDEMN RAPE – JUST AS WE CONDEMN EVERY WAR CRIME.
Sexual assault is devastating. Whether perpetrated by state or non-state actors; by strangers, acquaintances, friends or family members; by teachers, coaches, supervisors, co-workers or religious figures of any faith; by police, prison guards, soldiers or guerrilla fighters – we are very familiar with its enduring legacies of trauma and upheaval. And we condemn it equally in every instance.
We believe survivors and we believe reporting that results from investigations conducted by trained feminist and human rights experts who have no agenda other than to clearly and accurately document and convey the gravity of gender-based violence. Sexual assault is pervasive – even commonplace. It is rarely met with the outrage that its incidence, impact and enormity merit. And, history is also replete with examples of rape charges being wielded by stakeholders in armed conflict to render the “enemy” more monstrous – and thus as deserving of ever-more depraved forms of militarized violence. This tactic is as old as war itself. And this means that there are many reasons to distrust either the selective outrage – or protestations of innocence – of either governments or militias, or their respective propaganda organs, when it comes to sexual assault. There is an urgent need for increased public consciousness about how such outrage is mobilized during periods of conflict, and/or to legitimize racist agendas. And there is equivalent need for public awareness during moments when outrage is conspicuously absent – such as when members of those very governments or militias are accused of sexual abuses within their own ranks.
Israel’s current campaign to discredit feminists – especially feminists of color, Arab feminists and Jewish anti-zionist feminists – and others critical of its lethal offensive against Palestinians is insulting and dishonest, but it is nothing new. We see it for what it is: a cynical attempt to incite public fury and deflect attention from the genocide it is perpetrating. And far too many public figures and elected officials have allowed themselves to become participants in this onslaught of accusations against us.
So, let us once again make ourselves clear: We condemn rape. We condemn genocide. And we also condemn the opportunistic manipulation of the issue of sexual assault by those committing war crimes themselves – or by anyone else.
We support the investigation initiated by the highly-qualified members of the U.N. Commission of Inquiry into the entire range of war crimes committed during both the October 7 Hamas attack and the Israeli state’s subsequent assault on Gaza – an effort in which Israel thus far has refused to participate. We also support additional inquiries into these sexual assault allegations conducted by impartial feminist and human rights authorities with proven expertise in, and sensitivity about, sexual violence, as well as provision of a comprehensive range of services for all survivors by those explicitly trained in addressing sexual trauma. Additionally, we urge investigation into reported atrocities by both Israeli military personnel and non-state actors – including vigilante settler groups – throughout Israel and the Occupied Territories.
Finally, we continue to raise our voices as part of the world-wide call for a permanent ceasefire in Gaza, the release of all hostages and political prisoners, termination of U.S. military aid to Israel and an end to Israeli apartheid.
Below is a list of initial signers of this statement.
Please click here if you would like to add your name; the list will be updated periodically.
We encourage you to share this effort and invite others to sign on.
Amanda Lugg (US)
Ana Zentella, Professor Emerita, University of California San Diego (US)
Angela Y. Davis (US)
Anissa Helie, Feminist Historian (Algeria / US)
Ann Russo, DePaul University (US)*
Arlene Avakian, Professor Emeritus, University of Massachusetts Amherst (US)
Aurora Levins Morales, Writer (Puerto Rico)
Prof. Ayşe Gül Altınay, Sabancı University (Turkey)*
Dr. Barbara Ransby, Historian/Writer (US)
Barbara Schulman, Independent Advocate (US)
Barbara Smith, Black Feminist Author and Activist (US)
Dr. Barbara Klugman, Strategy and Evaluation Freelancer (South Africa)
Beverly Sheftall (US)
Blanche Wiesen Cook, University Distinguished Professor Emerita, John Jay College (US)
Carrie Shelver, Sexual Rights Initiative (South Africa)*
Catherine Hodes, LCSW/LICSW, Gender-Violence Advocate (US)
Prof. Chandra Talpade Mohanty, Distinguished Professor, Syracuse University (US)*
Charlotte Bunch, Founder, Center for Women’s Global Leadership (US)
Chitra Ganesh (US)
Cindy Engler (US)
Cindy Weisner, Grassroots Global Justice Alliance (US)*
Cynthia Rothschild, Independent Advocate (US)
Prof. David Kazanjian, English and Comparative Literature, University of Pennsylvania (US)*
Prof. Dianne Otto, Melbourne Law School (Australia)
Dubravka Zarkov, Associate Professor (retired), International Institute of Social Studies Netherlands (Serbia)
Ellen Gurzinsky (US)
Prof. Elizabeth Bernstein, Women's, Gender, and Sexuality Studies, Barnard College, Columbia University (US)*
Prof. Elora Chowdhury, Women's, Gender, & Sexuality Studies, University of Massachusetts Boston (US)*
Esther Farmer, Jewish Voice for Peace-NYC (US)*
Gillian Kane (US)
Prof. Gina Dent (US)
Prof. Gloria Careaga, Faculty of Psychology, National Autonomous University of Mexico (Mexico)*
Hema Sarang-Sieminski (US)
Prof. Hülya Adak (Turkey)
Ilana Landsberg-Lewis (Canada)
Indai Sajor, Independent Advocate (Philippines)
Jacqueline Woodson (US)
Prof. Jessie Daniels, PhD (US)
Joan Nestle (US / Australia)
Joanne Sandler (US)
Jodi Jacobson, Human Rights Advocate (US)
Joyce Yu (US)
Karen Zelermyer (US)
Kate Kroeger, Urgent Action Fund for Feminist Activism (US)*
Katherine Acey, Chair, Political Research Associates (US)*
Kathy Engel (US)
Kavita Nandini Ramdas, Principal, KNR Sisters; Activist in Residence and former President and CEO, Global Fund for Women (US / India)*
Kay Whitlock, Co-Author, Queer (In)Justice: The Criminalization of LGBT People in the US (US)
Prof. Ketu Katrak, University of California Irvine (US)*
Prof. Kiran Asher (US)
Laurie Woods, Independent Advocate for Women (US)
Lepa Mladjenovic, Feminist List Against Rape in War in the Region of Ex-Yugoslavia (Serbia)
Leslie Cagan (US)
Prof. Lila Abu-Lughod, Columbia University (US)*
Lisa Cartwright (US)
Prof. Lisa Duggan, New York University (US)*
Student Rabbi Louisa Solomon (US)
Lydia Alpízar Durán, Independent Advocate (Mexico / Costa Rica)
Margaret Cerullo, Professor Emerita, Hampshire College (US)
Margaret Randall (US)
Marion Stevens, Founding Director of the Sexual and Reproductive Justice Coalition and Stellenbosch University (South Africa)
Marjorie Fine (US)
Marla Erlien (US)
Rabbi May Ye, Jewish Voice for Peace Rabbinical Council (US)*
Prof. Miriam Ticktin (US)
Nathalie Arnold Koenings, Hampshire College (Belgium)
Prof. Nina Berman, Columbia Journalism School (US)*
Dr. Penny Rosenwasser, Kehilla Community Synagogue; Jewish Voice for Peace (US)*
Prof. Rebecca Jordan-Young, Department of Women’s, Gender, and Sexuality Studies, Barnard College (US)*
Rela Mazali, Writer, Independent Scholar, Activist (Israel)
Risa Shaw, PhD (US)
Prof. Rosalind Petchesky, Distinguished Professor Emerita, Hunter College & the Graduate Center-City University of New York; Member Leader, Jewish Voice for Peace-NYC (US)*
Roxanna Carrillo (Perú / US)
Sally Noland MacNichol, Anti-Violence Activist (US)
Samantha Kostmayer, Independent Advocate (US)
Sandy Martin, Feminist, Socialist, Activist (US)
Sara Lennox, Professor Emerita, University of Massachusetts Amherst (US)
Sarah Schulman (US)
Sarah Sills, Member Leader, Jewish Voice for Peace-NYC (US)*
Prof. Shahla Talebi, Arizona State University (US)*
Prof. Sima Shakhsari, University of Minnesota (US)*
Stephanie Roth, Member, Jewish Voice for Peace (US)*
Subha Wijesiriwardena, Feminist Activist, Researcher, Communicator (Sri Lanka / US)
Susan Lob, Founder, Voices of Women Organizing Project (US)*
Susana Fried (US)
Prof. Svati Shah (US)
Prof. Tami Kashia Gold (US)
Terry Greenblatt (US)
Yasmin Nair, Writer and activist (US)
Zillah Eisenstein, Professor Emerita, Writer, Activist (US)
*Affiliation included for identification purposes only
The following is a list of additional signers that will continue to be updated periodically.
Names are listed in the order in which they were received.
Please click here if you would like to add your name.