Idiots, No Longer Useful
Just a day before the publication of the column Idiots, No Longer Useful by noted Russian Marxist dissident Boris Kagarlitsky, the author was arrested by the FSB (Russian security police) and criminally charged for "justifying terrorism." As Kagarlitsky's associate on the Rabkor website Vasily Chapaev describes, other contributors to Rabkor were also searched and interrogated. The editors of Rabkor have issued an appeal to left socialist movements for international solidarity and for Kagarlitsky's release. -- moderator.
Idiots, No Longer Useful
by Boris Kagarlitsky
July 26, 2023
THIS MATERIAL (INFORMATION) IS PRODUCED, DISTRIBUTED AND (OR) DISTRIBUTED BY FOREIGN AGENT BORIS YULYEVICH KAGARLITSKY, OR RELATES TO THE ACTIVITIES OF FOREIGN AGENT BORIS YULIEVICH KAGARLITSKY.
“They can, but we can't.” We had to repeat this for many months, when left-wing and liberal oppositionists were detained and sent to trial for the mere word “war” uttered in connection with military operations on the territory of Ukraine, while Igor Strelkov and his associates criticized words of the military leadership, complained about defeats at the front, and talked openly about the terrible state of affairs in military units. Of course, they got away with it because they did not question the very need for military action. At first, Putin was not called by name and was not directly scolded. The government was reproached only for not being severe enough. With regard to Ukraine, they strictly adhered to the opinion that a country with such a name should not exist.
But everything has changed. On July 21 at 11:30 they came for Strelkov, FSB officers detaining the founder of the Angry Patriots Club. Earlier, charges were brought against retired colonel Vladimir Kvachkov, another well-known member of the Club. He is to be punished for discrediting the Russian army.
Of course, Strelkov crossed certain unwritten lines by making insulting remarks about Putin. But more importantly, the situation has changed.
Angry Patriots can justly be accused of aggressiveness and bloodthirstiness (and against the background of his comrades-in-arms, Strelkov is even one of the most moderate). Yet their main problem is not with their views per se, but in their monstrous political naivety and economic illiteracy, which just led them to where they are today. They did not understand that military operations have been conducted as competently and effectively as the current Russian state is capable of doing. They did not want to accept that the goals of this conflict had nothing to do with official statements (which, in any case, constantly contradicted themselves), or with beautiful dreams of restoring the Russian Empire or the USSR, about which the Angry Patriots continue to rave. The authorities, they say, have done everything right, and solved their problems as best they could. If you want it differently, then you need to change the state system and policy goals. But the trouble is, any sufficient changes would leave no room for either the current oligarchy, or for a “patriotic” agenda aimed at returning to an imaginary past.
A unique quality of the Russian elite is that it not only refuses to admit its mistakes, but also does not wish to be aware of the existence of objective problems (particularly those problems generated by its own actions). Instead of recognizing problems, the authorities only see threats, and they react to these threats in only one of two ways - by either lying on TV, or repression. The one, of course, is inseparable from the other.
The lies of modern Kremlin propagandists are radically different from what we saw in the USSR. In those days, propaganda was at least aimed at solving real strategic problems, at mobilizing support and public participation. Today, only an immediate justification of the current situation is required, while a change in course requires no explanation whatsoever, but only a refusal to recognize one's own past statements - they just didn't exist! The practice satirically described by Mr. Orwell in 1984 has become our daily routine. Nothing is required of society except political amnesia.
Strelkov and his Angry Patriots began to pose a threat not at the moment when they began to criticize the course of hostilities, but when they began to take seriously the rhetoric they'd been fed over the past year and a half.
We do not need to think about the regime's justification for why this whole operation was started. The authorities clearly don't take these seriously, as are clearly preparing for a major about-face. Officials at all different levels are well aware that it is necessary to leave the territory of Ukraine, the sooner the better. How this will be done, and most importantly by whom, we do not yet know. Putin clearly does not fit into these change of plans, but after the rebellion of Yevgeny Prigozhin, it is no secret to anyone that his reign is nearing its end. In the meantime, Angry Patriots can be silenced under the pretext of disrespect for the ruler. They have become much more dangerous than the left and liberal opposition, not because they offer some kind of alternative, or because they want or can change something, but because they stubbornly cling to the old agenda at the very moment when the ruling elites themselves are preparing to change this agenda. Angry Patriots create an ideological ferment for a conservative revolt. They cannot organize anything themselves, and they are not going to. But you never know how your own words will echo! What if people who have seen enough of TV will take the burdensome slogans that were proclaimed earlier too seriously? Respect for power in Russia today requires not support for its constantly changing official goals that contradict each other and contradict reality, but requires humility. A loyal public must be ready to be loyal to any decision. Then they will try to crush sincere patriots, admirers of the tsarist empire, militarists, nostalgic for the USSR, and simply those who memorized yesterday's mantras too tightly.
Yesterday's opposition may gloat today. But there is nothing good in this. No matter how wrong the Angry Patriots may be, no matter what terrible statements they make, they are punished not for their sins, not even for their principles, but for the fact that they have principles at all. Even if such measures herald an overdue change in policy, there is not the slightest reason to think that the next turn will be any more successful than the previous one. Problems are not only not solved, but they are not even recognized. Those in power are now beginning to understand that they still have to get out of the Ukrainian trap, into which they happily jumped a year and a half ago. But after that, the whole huge burden of other unresolved problems will fall on their - and our - heads.
However, if someone seriously tried to solve these problems in the sphere of economy, politics, management, social life, and international relations, there would be no Ukrainian campaign, no current situation, no Angry Patriots Club.
Translated by Dan Erdman
Boris Yulyevich Kagarlitsky is a Russian Marxist theoretician and sociologist who has been a political dissident in the Soviet Union. He is coordinator of the Transnational Institute Global Crisis project and Director of the Institute of Globalization and Social Movements (IGSO) in Moscow. Kagarlisky hosts a YouTube channel Rabkor, associated with his online newspaper of the same name and with IGSO.
Russian Dissent is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
'When They Came': The Detention of Boris Kagarlitsky
by Vasily Chapaev
July 25, 2023
THIS MATERIAL (INFORMATION) IS PRODUCED, DISTRIBUTED AND (OR) DISTRIBUTED BY THE FOREIGN AGENT BORIS YULYEVICH KAGARLITSKY, OR RELATES TO THE ACTIVITIES OF THE FOREIGN AGENT BORIS YULIEVICH KAGARLITSKY.
Boris Kagarlitsky was detained yesterday. Three more members of the Rabkor team were also detained. This news was shocking for me, a member of the editorial board and an author of articles on Rabkor. I know Boris as a true patriot of Russia, as a person who is not afraid to speak openly about problems in the state and offer ways to solve them. And all this Boris always says calmly, confidently, giving arguments and never slipping into demagoguery and insults, which Kremlin propagandists often suffer from.
That is why I first started watching Rabkor and Boris' streams, I really liked the level of discussion on the channel. What was my surprise when I decided to just write him a question in the chat and it was read live, and he answered it. Boris answered and answers everyone, answers honestly, openly, without concealment, even to personal and uncomfortable questions. This is what a real politician should be like, he should not be afraid of uncomfortable or provocative questions. Boris has always been open to ordinary people, to the people. So we began a correspondence, and then I began to write articles for Rabkor, because Boris speaks himself and allows everyone who has something to say to speak. To all those who cannot remain silent.
A variety of people came and continue to come to his streams, from ideological communists to hardened liberals, scientists, teachers, journalists, writers, poets, musicians, activists, farmers, businessmen, artists, governors, other politicians and even Kremlin propagandists. Everyone who has expressed a desire or responded to an invitation comes.
Boris Kagarlitsky gives the floor to everyone, he follows the principles of freedom of speech and freedom of opinion, exactly as it is guaranteed by Articles 28 and 29 of the Russian Constitution. According to it, “Everyone is guaranteed freedom of thought and speech. Propaganda or agitation that incite social, racial, national or religious hatred and enmity is not allowed. Propaganda of social, racial, national, religious or linguistic superiority is prohibited.” Boris never called for hatred and enmity, he is one of the most peaceful people I know. "No one can be forced to express their opinions and beliefs or to renounce them." However, it is for expressing his opinion that he is persecuted. “Freedom of the media is guaranteed. Censorship is prohibited." Boris has always stood for freedom of information and against censorship, all questions are read out at the worker's correspondent, not violating the laws of the Russian Federation. “Everyone is guaranteed freedom of conscience, freedom of religion, including the right to profess individually or jointly with others any religion or not to profess any, freely choose, have and disseminate religious and other beliefs and act in accordance with them.” Boris Kagarlitsky has always been someone who respects the opinions of others. He is an adherent of Marxist ideas, solidarity, peacefulness and scientific enlightenment.
I am sure that Boris’s conscience is clear and that he was arrested for justifying terrorism is a monstrous mistake by law enforcement agencies, because I have never heard that our editor-in-chief could somehow justify it, on the contrary, he always condemned terrorism and was against any terror in general, and political too. The arrest of Boris Kagarlitsky is a huge blow for the left movement, not only in Russia, but for leftists around the world. I call on everyone who adheres to leftist views, everyone who advocates freedom of speech, everyone who believes that people should not be persecuted for an opinion different from the opinion of the current government, to show solidarity and support! Politics in Russia should not be a crime!
I would like to end my address with a very famous quote:
“When they came for the communists, I was silent - I was not a communist.
When they came for the Social Democrats, I was silent - I was not a Social Democrat.
When they came for the trade union activists, I was silent - I was not a union member.
When they came for me, there was no one to intercede for me.”
Vasily Chapaev is a Rabkor author, Rostov on Don.
The electronic magazine Rabkor appeared in 2008, in the midst of the "first wave" of the global economic crisis, when confidence in the recipes of liberal economists was falling in Western Europe, and in Russia only the price of oil. The staff of the Institute of Globalization and Social Movements (IGSO) created this journal as a response to an urgent need for a daily left-wing Internet publication that offers the reader, instead of a trivial set of ideological mantras and slogans, an analysis of the current situation, a platform for debate and an overview of the development of social movements in Russia and the world.
For all questions (including authorship) write to email@example.com