Skip to main content

poetry The Unthinkable

"in a world where war is the natural state of affairs," writes the New York poet David Lehman, the unthinkable surrounds us all--the ones with "dough," "the refugee who cannot lost his German accent," even those whose aim is "to live at peace."

The Unthinkable



By David Lehman

                                        -- for Jess Smith, who prompted it



The recruit worked on ciphers and broke

the Soviets’ renowned “condor code” back

in September 1962, before the big crisis, when “missives“

meant “missiles,” and the way to win was to wink.



A wink got you out of any jam those days

when ballroom dancing was still in fashion

and young women in ball gowns thought the unthinkable

as they let clumsy cadets drag them across the floor.

The plink of fate is something that science can’t abolish

with its neutrons and angstroms and plancks and hadrons.

That is one reason why I turned my back on the merchants

of advanced micro devices, new chips, killer apps.

When I think of the life I could have led

on rush hour mornings, briefcase in hand

and Wall Street Journal under my arm, do I think

of all the dough I could have made?

No. I am luckier than

the refugee who cannot lose his German accent

in an office building on Liberty Street or even

at Harvard or the State Department.

My aim is not to be renowned,

to dance with Vera Ellen in a turtleneck

or Ginger Rogers in a ball gown. My aim is to live at peace

in a world where war is the natural state of affairs.

If you like this article, please sign up for Snapshot, Portside's daily summary.

(One summary e-mail a day, you can change anytime, and Portside is always free.)

The rules have changed, but I have allies in men and women

as young as I was when I first broke codes and committed odes

to memory, because we had neither paper nor pen and ink.

When I wink at you, it’s because I loved being alive when

I walked into the room. The unthinkable is nearer than you think

and can happen at any moment, like a collision or a disease

and we know this, and yet it always comes as a surprise.

Listen: Can you hear the muted plink?



David Lehman's books include Sinatra's Century: One Hundred Notes on the Man and His World (HarperCollins, 2015) and New and Selected Poems (Scribner, 2013).