Skip to main content

Marine Vet Lawmaker Tells Military to Question the Orders They're Given by Trump

Rep. Seth Moulton, D-Mass., a longtime outspoken critic of Trump's policies and decisions, has publicly voiced concerns with the decision to kill Soleimani in the days following his death, saying the consequences of the strike were unclear.

"I was only following orders," has been unsuccessfully used as a legal defense in hundreds of cases (probably most notably by Nazi leaders at the Nuremberg tribunals following World War II).,Photo by Alex Wong/Getty Images // JustSecurity

A lawmaker who earned the Bronze Star during combat in Iraq as a Marine officer is denouncing President Donald Trump's foreign policy as "rudderless," and calling on active-duty military officers to question the orders they're getting from the commander in chief and refuse to follow them if they're not lawful.

Rep. Seth Moulton, a Massachusetts Democrat and former presidential candidate who ended his White House bid in August, made the remarks in a speech at the Atlantic Council on Thursday, a day after Trump triumphantly addressed the nation and announced that Iran seemed to be backing down from hostilities.

On Jan. 3, a U.S. MQ-9 Reaper drone executed a deadly airstrike on Iranian Quds Force commander Maj. Gen. Qasem Soleimani; Iran retaliated Jan. 7 with a ballistic missile assault on two Iraqi bases that damaged equipment and buildings but did not harm U.S. or Iraqi troops.

Moulton called for Trump to declassify and release the legal notification he sent to Congress regarding what officials have called an "imminent attack" planned by Soleimani that necessitated his assassination.

"If there is intelligence that shows this strike prevented a new and imminent threat to Americans, I have yet to see it," Moulton said, according to prepared remarks. " ... I fought in a war a president started because of cooked and false intelligence; we cannot let this Administration repeat that mistake."

The Pentagon has joined the White House in describing the purported attack plan as "imminent;" Defense Secretary Mark Esper told reporters it was accurate to describe it as days away at the time of Soleimani's death.

Moulton, a longtime outspoken critic of Trump's policies and decisions, has publicly voiced concerns with the decision to kill Soleimani in the days following his death, saying the consequences of the strike were unclear.

"I do not mourn for this man who is directly responsible for some 600 American deaths in Iraq -- a few of whom were my friends," Moulton said in his Atlantic Council Speech. "But it is not that simple. It was telling, that of every fellow veteran who texted me the night he was killed, not one celebrated his death -- though they too, I'm sure, would much rather him dead than alive. They said, 'What the hell is going on here?' And, 'Please tell me there's a plan.' Sadly, I've seen no evidence that there is."

Iran, he added, is unlikely to let a "zero-casualty ballistic missile strike" settle the score between the two countries.

If you like this article, please sign up for Snapshot, Portside's daily summary.

(One summary e-mail a day, you can change anytime, and Portside is always free.)

The Trump administration needs to develop a clear policy regarding Iran, and to refocus on the greatest foreign threats to the nation, including China, Moulton said.

"And for those members of our military in the chain of command, here in Washington or overseas -- look very carefully at every order given to you by this president," Moulton said. "It is our duty to make sure everything done in the name of the United States military is lawful; and that burden falls on us. ... We have an opportunity to call on our military officers around the world to bring new scrutiny to their sworn oath to obey lawful orders, and only lawful orders."

The issue of lawful orders came to the fore this month when Trump threatened to destroy Iranian cultural sites if the country escalated the conflict, an act that would fall afoul of international law. The president ultimately backed down from those threats, and Esper said the U.S. military would not commit such an act and did not expect to be ordered to do so.

Moulton, who voted to impeach Trump in December, served in the Marine Corps from 2001 to 2008. He assumed office in January 2015.

[Hope Hodge Seck is an award-winning investigative and enterprise reporter who has been covering military issues since 2009. She is managing editor for

Hope’s previous assignments have included a war zone embed in Afghanistan with Marines and multiple reporting trips aboard amphibious ships and aircraft carriers. Her awards include multiple North Carolina Press Association Honors, the 2015 and 2017 Marine Corps Heritage Foundation Heinl awards for feature writing, the Military Reporters and Editors Association 2015 award for domestic military coverage, and the 2016 American Legion 4th Estate Award for print reporting. She is also a member of the board of directors at the Military Reporters and Editors Association.

A graduate of The King's College in New York City, her work has also appeared in Marine Corps Times, Newsweek, USA Today, The New York Sun, and World Magazine. Email: ]